From diagnosis to remedy
Saad Al-Rawi
Former Deputy Chairman of the Board of Commissioners of Iraq’s Independent High Electoral Commission (IHEC)
Writer and consultant specialising in elections
Many electoral laws, Iraq’s among them, reserve seats to guarantee minorities a place in national and local legislatures. However, a seat in parliament or on a provincial council is not the same as a right secured. Wider representation does not by itself deliver justice. Iraq’s minorities continue to voice grievances, and those grievances must be understood and remedied through sound legal means. This paper briefly reviews the legal and judicial texts that govern minority quotas. It then sets out the main problems they leave unresolved and proposes ways to address them.
What the law says
Iraq’s minority quotas rest on four main texts.
The first is the Law on Elections of Provincial and District Councils, No. 12 of 2018. Article 15 reserves a set of seats for named minority communities. These seats come in addition to the regular seats of councils in provinces that do not belong to a federal region, which in practice means every province outside the Kurdistan Region. The reserved seats total nine. Each one goes to the list that wins the most votes, and within that list to the candidate with the highest individual tally.
The second is the Law on Elections of the Council of Representatives, No. 9 of 2020. Article 13 fixes the size of parliament at 329 seats. Of these, 320 are distributed among the provinces according to their administrative boundaries until a general census is held. The remaining nine form the minority quota. The quota is counted within the total allocation of seats, and minorities who also run on national lists keep their full share. The law places the quota seats of Christians and Sabean-Mandaeans within a single electoral district.
The third is the seat allocation regulation issued in 2021 by the Independent High Electoral Commission (IHEC), the body that runs Iraq’s elections. Article 3 distributes the nine quota seats as the law prescribes. It also provides that minority candidates who win general seats do not cost their community its reserved seats.
The fourth is a ruling by the Federal Supreme Court, Iraq’s highest constitutional authority, reported by Shafaq News on 22 February 2022. The court found the current form of parliamentary representation for three smaller communities, the Yazidis, the Shabak and the Feyli Kurds, to be unconstitutional. It ruled that these communities must stand on an equal footing with Christians and Sabean-Mandaeans. The court grounded its decision in the need to strengthen their national role, uphold equality and preserve national unity.
Space does not allow a fuller account of these texts. The rest of this paper turns to the problems they leave open and to proposals for securing minority rights in practice.
Where the texts fall short
The texts do not shield any community from violations of its rights. They need extensive clarification before minorities, and Iraqis more broadly, can secure their rights in full.
Taken together, the provisions do little more than guarantee a seat or two to one minority or another. Minority rights remain loosely defined, and this leaves the reserved seats easy prey for large parties and coalitions. The rights of minorities end up at the mercy of those parties.
The voter register compounds the problem. Iraq uses a single general register that covers every community in the country. Any voter may cast a ballot for a quota candidate. A party or coalition can direct its supporters to back a candidate it sponsors in a minority race and capture the seat reserved for that community.
The weakness runs deeper than electoral rules. Awareness of democratic values and human rights remains limited among Iraqis in general, minorities included. This has dampened interest in elections and made it harder for minority voters to choose representatives capable of defending their rights and speaking genuinely on their behalf.
A minority without genuine representation will always find its rights in doubt.
What can be done
The starting point is the rule of law. In a democracy, no one stands above the law or beyond accountability. Until Iraq upholds this principle, citizens will struggle to obtain the rights that the constitution and the laws in force guarantee them.
Iraq also lacks parties and coalitions with national programmes that embrace all Iraqis without distinction. Quotas and minority legislation cannot fix this. The task falls to the country’s national elites and professionals, who must develop such programmes and bring an end to the injustices suffered by minorities and other Iraqis.
Should a national Iraqi project prove out of reach, minorities should build political projects of their own. They could form a single joint movement. Alternatively, each community could create its own political grouping and cooperate with the others in a United Minorities Coalition. Such a coalition would need a detailed common programme and internal bylaws that define its working methods, the division of roles and powers, and the way it takes decisions.
Minorities should press for a separate voter register for each community. The register would record where its members live and how many they are. Seats could then be distributed fairly and on a sound basis rather than arbitrarily.
Once these registers are complete, the electoral law should allow only registered members of a minority to vote for its quota seats. This would curb the ability of large parties to steer their voters towards a minority candidate and seize the seat in that community’s name.
Further legislation should guarantee minorities a fair share of positions in government, in independent bodies, and in local and national administrations. These measures could be temporary. They would remain in place until parties with national programmes take root and go on to form local and national governments.
Iraq should also establish a specialised institute or centre for minorities. It would provide legal and democratic education and human rights training to minority citizens, working with international organisations and specialised centres abroad. A detailed proposal for such a body could be drafted separately.
These are, in brief, my views on the rights of minorities and on how to address the problems they face in our country.
